When I was in high school my friends and I debated the issue of music frequently. Now, you’re probably saying “There’s an issue of music?!?!?”. In a word, no, there really isn’t. But we didn’t know that then.
You see I grew up in an independent, fundamental, Baptist church. Making issues out of non-issues was an art form to us – everything from women wearing pants (not that they promoted pants-less women, but that women should only wear skirts and dresses), to Bible versions. The big one for us though was whether Christian Contemporary Music, or Christian Rock as we called it, was God honoring. This was probably the most heated topic for me and my friends, being that we were extremely drawn to musical expression.
I have no desire to address these issues in a blog – I walked away from these idiotic ideals years ago and have no intention of ever returning. For those of you that are still distracted by them, let me share with you what I have learned in the last ten years: Pants on women are fine though I really like skirts, no version is inspired by God, and Christian Rock might have a better chance of honoring God if it didn’t suck so much.
Some good did come out of our pubescent debates. I remember beginning to form my own philosophy of art and its role in the Christian’s life. But I also remember a line that the anti-CCM folks used to use on me that I actually agree with. They would say that Christian Rock is nothing more than “Jesus is my boyfriend” music. Basically meaning that if you just took out Jesus’ name and replaced it with the word “baby”, you’d pretty much just have another run-of-the-mill pop song. I saw some validity to this thinking because it did annoy me that some songs seem to take the transcendent concepts of grace, love and forgiveness and bring them down to the level of a simple, junior-high infatuation. Again, I have no desire to blog about these types of songs because I think that I have also walked away from that kind of meaninglessness years ago.
But that line of reasoning has helped me realize that there is a category of music out there that counters the “Jesus is my boyfriend” crap. It’s when a song about earthly truths suddenly transcends its intent to heavenly meaning. It’s when the songwriter hits a note inside of you that is so deep, that it is not only a good relationship song, it becomes a worship song of sorts.
The best example I can think of this is “With or Without You”, by U2. Yes, yes – U2 has been my favorite band since I was 15 so I am a little biased, but this song strikes a chord in a lot of us that is not just earthly in meaning. Now I’ll be the first to admit that I really have no idea what intent Bono had when writing it. He seems to be very spiritual and a fellow believer in Jesus, but there is nothing that says to me that this song is about God anymore than it is about a girl. Yet there is something about the words, his emotion, the musical build that just resonates within me something meaningful. At the song’s climax, when the only vocal is one of no words at all, just Oh-Oh-Oh-Oh, one can sense a yearning and a hurt that just relates to me on a very spiritual level. Perhaps it has less to do with the spiritual intent of the author, but more the interconnectedness of our earthly relationships with our spiritual nature – that we were truly designed to love God with all of our heart as well as our neighbor as ourselves. That “neighborly” love then makes the best pictures that we have of Jesus – through the expressions of each other.
I realize that this observation of mine is subjective, but I wonder if any of you have also observed this about your favorite songs, movies, books, or works of art.
This thought process and subsequent blog was inspired by the song “Transatlanticism”, by Death Cab for Cutie. Some other songs that hit me this way are “Reservations” by Wilco, and “Let Go” by Frou Frou (although very aptly covered by Boys like Girls).
By the way – sorry for the lame youtube videos, but I wanted to give you all a chance to hear the above songs without seeing some amateur video of a 14 year old boy interpretive dancing to these beautiful songs! The words can speak for themselves.


